I wanted to make a flat thrust bearing (similar to a lazy susan) using
marbles. The generic 9/16" marbles I had were white, yellow,
green, blue, black and red in color. Each color marble was a slightly
different diameter and none of them were exactly round.
The track was routed into the wood using a 5/8" diameter core box bit. The white marbles are slightly over 9/16" diameter while the smallest red ones are well under 9/16" diameter.
Being slightly out-of-round or egg-shape means they will not
roll uniformly around the track. This can be easily demonstrated by just
pushing one of the marbles around the track and observing how quickly it
stops. The largest ones stop quickly and the smallest (black, blue, and
red) make it all the way around with a gentle push.
I tried the bearing using only the smallest black, blue, and red marbles.
This works but the race runs quite rough and it is noisy.
I replaced the marbles with 5/8" diameter steel ball bearings, which are
perfectly round and of exact diameter. The bearing now runs quite
smoothly and much quieter, but the rotation can be a bit erratic because
the bearings running into each other interfere with their rotation.
Looking at one bearing traveling left to right, the rear of the bearing
is turning upward and the bearing directly behind it is turning
downward. When they contact each other they effectively are trying to
zero out the rotation between them.
Spacing the bearings evenly around the track and preventing them from
running into each other is accomplished by using a cage. I made the cage
from tempered hard-board. The holes in the cage are 11/16" diameter.
Now the bearing runs very smoothly.
Then I decided to try the bearing cage with the different size (color)
marbles. The cage improves the bearing but the marbles are still
out-of-round and run rough.
I'll stick with the 5/8" ball bearings. They work the best.
Sometimes you can get ahead of yourself in a project or change your mind
about how something should work. I already cut the center out of the
large wood section, and then later decided to add the bearing race.
Before I could route the bearing track, I needed to accurately relocate
the center in this large wood workpiece. The following video explains a
solution I came up with for relocating the center.