Alan Lester is co-owner of
Karhu Fine Cabinetry & millwork.
They make custom built in cabinetry and Millwork,
mostly for high end homes. There's a
gallery of some of their work on their website.
Most orders come in through designers who work on custom houses and renovations. They don't make kitchens for new subdivisions, because the builders primarily want many identical kitchens at the lowest possible price.
Alan showed me around the shop. It's a busy place, with about
20 people working there.
At left, a 24" thickness planer and a 16" jointer. Alan says he didn't really need the jointer to be that wide, but he needed one that was 8' (2.4 meters) long and sturdy. (it's definitely sturdier than the one I built!)
Looking along the new wing of the building. This part was only added last year (2011),
and holds most of the larger machines -- machines that would be the envy
of many a hobby woodworker.
But it's not all fun and games. The business is about building custom cabinetry. Although it's working with wood, it's very different from the sort of woodworking that magazines such as Popular Woodworking or Fine Woodworking write about.
Alan says he has to be careful about hiring people who say they are "into woodworking". These people may be amazed by the equipment, but they usually aren't a good fit for production work.
For solid woods, Alan says
"We use cherry the most, but quarter cut and rift cut white oak are
becoming very popular. We also use a fair amount of walnut and a bit of maple."
Although wood is not cheap, they usually buy a little extra to be safe. "Compared to the cost of the time and labour for making up for being short one piece, wood is cheap".
For large panels Alan prefers veneered particle board and MDF. About Baltic birch. He says that Baltic birch "often comes to us twisted. Particle board and MDF are generally flat and stay that way."
I was a bit aghast at having my favourite plywood compared unfavourably to MDF. After all, I made jointer tables from it and they stayed flat. I'm happy if my one set of hand-picked and carefully treated surfaces stays flat. But if one in ten panels for a cabinet job is warped, that's unacceptable for a business.
And I have to say, I was surprised at how much less balancing my bandsaw wheels from MDF needed even compared to Baltic birch. The more finely chopped and mixed the wood is, the less likely it is to warp.
A vertical panel saw for cutting up the panels
And an old Delta Unisaw. Alan says "Not much can go wrong with a Unisaw.
That saw was already 30 years old when we bought it 30 years ago".
They also have a Felder table saw. This one is not a combination machine.
Alan isn't a big fan of it "not all they are cracked up to be", he says.
I watched a guy make some cuts on this saw that would have been easier on a smaller saw. I asked "why don't' you just get a cheap saw for doing that sort of cut". "There's no such thing as a cheap saw" Alan responded. "Even a cheap machine needs floor space, needs to be wired in by an electrician, and needs to be plumbed to the dust extraction. And then how often would you use it? It's too easy to get carried away buying lots of equipment".
I guess Alan doesn't live by the motto of "whoever has the most toys wins". For a business, that makes sense. For a hobbyist, it's a different matter. :)
Most of the panel cutting is done with a CNC machine these days.
The CNC machine is from Biesse. The name "Skill" on the gantry refers to the
model, no relation to skillsaws.
The machine has a 5' x 12' bed (1.5m x 3.6m)
This machine is very different from your typical hobbyist CNC machine. It's
equipped with a tool change turret. Most of the cutting is done with a 1/2" (13 mm)
cutter. The wider cutter wastes slightly more material, but higher feed rates can be
achieved. They typically cut 3/4" panels in a single pass, with the cutter spinning
at 25000 RPM and a feed rate of 22 meters/minute
That's 36 cm (15") of cut every second. That would be fast even for a table saw.
Also visible is the "drilling block" which can drill many holes at once. These are for shelf pins and mounting European style hardware.
Aside from saving a lot of labour, the CNC machine also leads to greater accuracy.
| This is the edge bander. That's a machine few hobbyists would know what to do with, but for cabinet shops, these are essential. |
| A view from the mezzanine onto the original part of the shop. This looks crowded, but it used to be much more crowded before they added the wing that now holds most of the large machines. (flickr gallery of its construction) |
Except for the heavy machines, most things are on wheels. This used to be much more
important before they added on to the shop.
Seeing many DeWalt tools, I asked Alan about his preferences:
"For the more common power tools (drills, drivers, jig saws)
I have tried the more expensive brands and found they don't last any longer,
or not enough to justify the cost difference. In the end it comes down to cost.
I almost never pay full price for power tools. I watch the Home Depot fliers
and buy when there's a sale on. For the more expensive common tools like
routers and miter saws I go to the DeWalt repair centre and buy re-built tools.
Generally about 2/3 to 3/4 regular price. But... they don't always have what
you want in stock. For the oddball tools, like the Festool domino, we have no
choice but to buy the expensive brand. I should also mention that I buy the
cheapest biscuit jointer out there, the Freud JS 100A.
I've been buying it for 25 years. It's not fancy, but it works well and
at $125 it's disposable. Another tool we've been buying for ever is the
Makita 3 x 24" 9924DB belt sander. I tend to find a tool that works for
us and stick to it. Then I can scavenge parts occasionally, but more importantly
the guys are comfortable with them. Then there's no breaking in period as
they get used to a different tool."
A shop-made downdraft table.
The slots in the downdraft table were a quick job on the CNC machine.
They use a lot of air tools. Alan says the air tools generally last longer than their electrical equivalents, though not so much with the orbital sanders because they don't oil them like they should. The oil has a tendency to get out of the sander and onto the work. They get about a year out of these sanders before they wear out.
With a lot of air tools in use, there's a need for a suitable compressor.
They used to run a 15-horsepower piston compressor, rated 60 CFM. But it was loud,
and with multiple sanders each using 18 CFM, it wasn't always able to keep up.
They upgraded to a screw compressor, which is smaller and quieter, with greater capacity.
In such a large shop, there's also a need for a lot of dust extraction.
They currently have a 30 HP dust extractor. The previous one,
a 7 1/2 HP Oenida wasn't enough for the shop as it grew. It's for sale,
contact Alan
if you are interested.
The painting booth (far corner in this photo) vents to the outside,
pulling about 8000 CFM out of the shop. A 1,000,000 BTU make-up
unit heats up replacement air. The BTU and airflow of that furnace
are about ten times that of a residential furnace. This makes for over $7000 in
annual heating costs. Not quite ten times that of a house, because
the spray booth is not in continuous operation.
I asked Alan about using a heat exchanger to recover some of the heat from the paint booth exhaust. "Heat exchangers for spray room exhausts don't exist to my knowledge".
There are many rules and regulations relating to labour, safety, and the environment, and spray booths are especially difficult in this regard. Sometimes rules from different bureaucracies even conflict with each other.
That all these rules might handicap a business man not concern a government inspector. But in the mean time, there is competition from China, where wages are low and people and the environment are treated almost as expendable.
Some painted doors, drying.
Most cabinet shops buy the doors pre-made, but it's hard to get consistent quality and good colour match that way, so Karhu builds most of their cabinet doors from scratch. The costs work out to about the same as buying pre-made doors.
But not everything is made from scratch. These solid hardwood drawers were
bought pre-made from a company in Quebec "For less than we can make them for"
says Alan. The quality is good, with very few defects.
Bandsaws don't play much of a role in cabinet work. In fact, when I checked out
Gregor Bruhn's shop, there wasn't even a
bandsaw in the shop. Karhu only has one 14" bandsaw, "and it might not even
be properly set up" says Alan.
Very different from my tinkering where the bandsaw is one of my most used machines. Despite all the nice equipment they have, for my type of work, I'm better off in my modest basement workshop where I have the tools I use the most all close together.
That said, they also make the occasional non-cabinet piece of furniture at Karhu,
roughly two per month, if a designer they work with calls for something
different. By hobbyist standards, that's still a lot, but it's
a small volume compared to the cabinetry business.
With the business the size it is, Alan mostly works on administration these days.
Although when they are short handed, he'll also work the shop floor.
Despite doing it professionally, Alan still enjoys doing some wood turning and wood working as a hobby. Here's his bowl turning lathe, along with some rough-turned bowls. Bowls are turned rough from green (not yet dried) wood. They are then let dry. Drying causes warping to some extent, but with the thick walls on the rough-turned bowls, they can still be turned completely round again.
Touring an organ building workshop
